Packaging Design Mistakes That Are Costing You Sales (And How to Fix Them)
It’s easy to overlook the role packaging plays in your bottom line, but make no mistake, it’s one of the most powerful sales tools you have. When done right, packaging draws customers in, builds trust, and enhances the product experience. When done wrong? It creates confusion, disappointment, or even drives customers away. If your sales aren’t where they should be, your packaging could be part of the problem. Let’s break down the most common packaging mistakes that are quietly costing you revenue and exactly how to fix them.
Mistakes That Hurt First Impressions
Customers often judge a product before they ever touch it, and packaging is usually the first thing they see.
Overcomplicating the Design: Too much clutter, too many fonts, or unclear messaging can confuse a buyer. Keep it focused: What’s the product? Who is it for? Why should they care?
Not Communicating Value: If your packaging doesn’t highlight your product’s core benefit or what makes it different, customers may pass right by. Make sure the value is obvious.
Using Generic or Unbranded Packaging: Packaging that lacks a strong visual identity feels forgettable, and forgettable products don’t get recommended or repurchased. You want customers to remember and recognize your brand.
Mistakes That Undermine Trust and Quality
Your packaging can either build confidence or raise red flags. Here’s what may be working against you.
Flimsy or Low-Quality Materials: Customers associate packaging quality with product quality. If the box is thin or the label peels easily, they may question the integrity of what’s inside.
Difficult to Open or Use: Packaging that’s hard to open, leaks, or creates a mess turns a good product into a bad experience. Customers remember frustration more than they remember good design.
Not Matching the Price Point: If you’re charging premium prices but the packaging doesn’t reflect that, it creates disconnect and disappointment. Your design and materials should match the perceived value.
Mistakes That Lose Customers After the Sale
Great packaging continues the experience after purchase, and builds the emotional connection that leads to loyalty.
No Unboxing Experience: Skipping thoughtful touches like custom inserts, care cards, or even a simple thank-you note makes your brand feel transactional instead of personal.
No Reuse or Disposal Plan: If the packaging is hard to recycle or just feels wasteful, it may leave a bad impression. Sustainable, reusable, or clearly recyclable packaging helps build trust with today’s conscious buyers.
No Follow-Up or Call to Action: Once they open the box, what happens next? Including a discount code, a QR code to follow your brand, or an invite to join your community keeps them in your orbit.
Packaging Should Be Helping You Sell Not Holding You Back
If you’re investing time, energy, and money into your product but your packaging is an afterthought, it’s time for a shift. Small tweaks can make a big difference, visually, emotionally, and financially.
Ready for professional packaging design? Inquire here to work with me and we’ll go make your packaging strategic, sustainable, and connection-focused.
And if you're not quite ready to redesign yet, join my newsletter for monthly packaging tips and brand insights built for small business owners.
Your packaging should be your best silent salesperson. Let’s make sure it’s doing its job.